It turns out a new expert in Wi-Fi technology also spends his time running Lakehead University in Thunder Bay, Ont. Fred Gilbert, the university's president, has banned Wi-Fi on campus because he believes it potentially has "some fairly significant" health consequences based on some literature he's read. So Fred, what makes you think this research is so conclusive? You got any concrete evidence it's true? And what makes you such an expert when Wi-Fi networks are being established everywhere from hotels to hospitals? Just out of curiosity, Fred, what's your take on reports that cell phones cause brain cancer? It is somewhat ironic that at a time when "Wi-Fi Fred" bans wireless networks, Via Rail is launching Wi-Fi on it trains.
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Who's Fred Gilbert and What Does He Know about Wi-Fi?
by
Mark Evans
on Wed 22 Feb 2006 02:26 PM EST | Permanent Link
It turns out a new expert in Wi-Fi technology also spends his time running Lakehead University in Thunder Bay, Ont. Fred Gilbert, the university's president, has banned Wi-Fi on campus because he believes it potentially has "some fairly significant" health consequences based on some literature he's read. So Fred, what makes you think this research is so conclusive? You got any concrete evidence it's true? And what makes you such an expert when Wi-Fi networks are being established everywhere from hotels to hospitals? Just out of curiosity, Fred, what's your take on reports that cell phones cause brain cancer? It is somewhat ironic that at a time when "Wi-Fi Fred" bans wireless networks, Via Rail is launching Wi-Fi on it trains.
Comments
Re: Who's Fred Gilbert and What Does He Know about Wi-Fi?
by
Tris Hussey
on Wed 22 Feb 2006 02:35 PM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
I guess he doesn't use cordless phones either ... since it's the same spectrum.
Re: Who's Fred Gilbert and What Does He Know about Wi-Fi?
by
Anonymous
on Wed 22 Feb 2006 02:46 PM EST | Permanent Link
I hear you can fashion a helmet out of tinfoil to protect
yourself from all of this. Tell Fred it works great for blocking unwanted government mind reading and brain scans as well :) Mike B Re: Who's Fred Gilbert and What Does He Know about Wi-Fi?
by
Stuart MacDonald
on Wed 22 Feb 2006 07:50 PM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
Via has actually had wifi on some of their trains for quite a while now. In Via 1 cars, on at least some trains between Toronto and Montreal, anyway. It was a free beta for a while, then went to a paid service. It is awesome - sit there, with space, a plug, GPRS and wifi webtone? And a glass of wine? Sweetness.
-- Stuart Re: Who's Fred Gilbert and What Does He Know about Wi-Fi?
by
Tyler
on Thu 23 Feb 2006 01:41 AM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
Took several decades before the effects of asbestos were understood. Takes more than 10 years for most cancers to show themselves in response to an environmental condition. Several credible studies, many out of Sweden, have looked at cell phone use 10 years or beyond and have found slight increases in certain cancers. Others have found effects on learning and conditions such as headaches.
Most of us haven't used cell phones that long, let alone used Wi-Fi. Yeah, this guy is perhaps overly paranoid, but I wouldn't write off anybody as crazy until enough time has passed. BTW: Last week the city of Salzburg in Austria banned Wi-Fi in all public schools. So Fred ain't the only one concerned about kids. The Brits, having concluded that kids should limit cell phone exposure, have just launched their own study into Wi-Fi. I'm a big lover in wireless technologies, but I'm not about to completely dismiss potential long-term health issues related to electromagnetic frequencies just because the industry, and industry-funded studies, suggest it's safe. That said, we're so bathed in these frequencies that if a problem ever does emerge we'll all be doomed anyways. Re: Re: Who's Fred Gilbert and What Does He Know about Wi-Fi?
by
Stuart MacDonald
on Thu 23 Feb 2006 09:43 AM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
Fair comment across the board, Tyler. Including the last line :-(
-- Stuart Re: Re: Who's Fred Gilbert and What Does He Know about Wi-Fi?
by
Mark Evans
on Thu 23 Feb 2006 11:42 AM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
the voice of reason! good points but i'd like to see how gilbert made his decision. it looks rather arbitrary.
Re: Re: Re: Who's Fred Gilbert and What Does He Know about Wi-Fi?
by
Anonymous
on Thu 23 Feb 2006 01:43 PM EST | Permanent Link
I thought Salzberg was all about preventing GSM antennas/towers from being near schools?
The UK work referred to was conducted on kids under age 12. The argument was that since skull bone tissue was not fully developed kids might (it was not conclusive) be at risk. As far as I know kids under 12 do not attend Lakehead. Re: Re: Who's Fred Gilbert and What Does He Know about Wi-Fi?
by
gordwick
on Mon 01 Oct 2007 08:49 AM EDT | Profile | Permanent Link
Tell me about it... I personally don't feel safe anymore: risk of cancer is in the air, in the water, in food, and of course everywhere. You have really good points here, you said it all for me. We have to ways in the next 10 years: find the perfect cure for every type of cancer or simply comply and accept the facts...
Gordman, Mesothelioma Law Suits Re: Who's Fred Gilbert and What Does He Know about Wi-Fi?
by
Anonymous
on Thu 23 Feb 2006 12:30 PM EST | Permanent Link
You are clueless.
WiFi and Cellphones both run on radio waves. This is a fact. There is no debate in the scientific community about the fact that radio waves give you cancer.
Radio waves will give you cancer in large enough doses.
The only debate is how much. WiFi and cellphones emit very small amounts of radio waves and no conclusive resarch has been found that can prove that these small amounts are enough to give you cancer. That is the only point you can argue without showing your complete ignorance of the subject.
Re: Re: Who's Fred Gilbert and What Does He Know about Wi-Fi?
by
Sean
on Thu 23 Feb 2006 01:40 PM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
Nice netiquette. Next time, why not change your tone to something a little more constructive and help edify us all.
Re: Re: Who's Fred Gilbert and What Does He Know about Wi-Fi?
by
Tyler
on Thu 23 Feb 2006 06:51 PM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
Unless, Mr. "Anonymous", you're some neurosurgeon hiding behind the Web, I'd be careful about who you call clueless. I've talked to the former head of the World Health Organization, reputable scientists and neurosurgeons around the world, and top-level health officials in Canada, and while there's no general agreement, they all agree that not enough time has passed to make the kinds of judgements you just made. The only ones who consistently make those judgements are the industry itself.
I've got a Wi-Fi network at home, occasionally use a cell phone and have baby monitors galor throughout my house. I'm not saying this is bad stuff, I'm saying people have their reasons for being concerned, just given the very fact that something is "not conclusive." If you had some crazy-looking mole taken off your ass and the doctor came back and said the bioopsy was "inconclusive," would you go home and not worry about it? Re: Re: Re: Who's Fred Gilbert and What Does He Know about Wi-Fi?
by
Sean
on Fri 24 Feb 2006 09:20 AM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
Spot on, Tyler. I seem to recall that smoking use to not be a cause of cancer. Anyone out there disputing modern medicine on that one these days?
Re: Re: Who's Fred Gilbert and What Does He Know about Wi-Fi?
by
Anonymous
on Thu 21 Sep 2006 12:07 PM EDT | Permanent Link
First off not claiming to a be an expert on this subject, but I will share some information.
The last point of radio waves I get... but we have been surrounded by those since day one. Radios have been around for close to a hundred years, right? From what I understand... it isn't necessarily the radio waves... it is the EMFs (Electro Magnetic Frequencies) produced during operation of portable electronics. Cell phones among other things like computers, cars, and above all Microwaves emit these EMFs that disrupt our biofield. This biofield that surrounds our entire body controls our stress levels and our over all well-being. These EMFs change our resonating frequency causing headaches in some cases. The constant saturation of these EMFs is thought to cause cancer. Some interesting points have been brought up here... Asbestos, Smoking... these things weren't proven until well after their usage. There have also been recent developments to neutralize EMFs in the form of a pendant form. If you have ever watched the golf network, advertisements for a product called the 'Q-link' can be seen. From what I understand nearly every professional golfer including Tiger Woods wears this jewlery that neutralizes harmful frequencing allowing for better focus and concentration. http://www.qlinkgolf.com/Scripts/default.asp hope this helps everyone... btw... I do wear a 'Q Link' and I feel the benefits Re: Who's Fred Gilbert and What Does He Know about Wi-Fi?
by
Tris Hussey
on Thu 23 Feb 2006 02:14 PM EST | Profile | Permanent Link
And it looks like its made the International press ...
http://news.com.com/2061-11199_3-6042429.html?part=rss&tag=6042429&subj=news Re: Who's Fred Gilbert and What Does He Know about Wi-Fi?
by
Anonymous
on Mon 27 Feb 2006 02:02 PM EST | Permanent Link
Just so you are made aware, Lakehead University does have a full time daycare in the middle of campus with dozens of children. They also host several summer-long science camps for kids.
P.S. How long was it before they told people not to build under power lines? Re: Who's Fred Gilbert and What Does He Know about Wi-Fi?
by
Anonymous
on Thu 09 Mar 2006 03:40 PM EST | Permanent Link
"So Fred, what makes you think this research is so conclusive? You got any concrete evidence it's true?"
Any concrete evidence that it's not? Err on the side of caution, I say. Re: Who's Fred Gilbert and What Does He Know about Wi-Fi?
by
california drug rehabilitation
on Fri 25 Jan 2008 09:47 AM EST | Permanent Link
I've seen this guy on tv. He was speaking and don't know why I wasn't believing a single thing.
Trackbacks
TrackBack URL: Weblogs that reference this article:
|
My blog has moved.
Check out the new Mark Evans. It's on Wordpress and part of my mini-blog empire that also includes All About Nortel You can subscribe to Mark Evans Tech by clicking on the RSS symbol above.
Check Out These Blogs
Search
Login
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||