The much-awaited U.S. court ruling came down today involving Research in
Motion's three-year patent dispute with NTP Inc. Anyone who was expecting a
clear-cut decision will be disappointed as the court appeared to rule in
favor of RIM in some parts and for NTP in others. To make matters worse, the
court sent the whole kit and kaboodle back to a lower court for
reconsideration. While both sides will likely claim victory, it is likely
this exercise - which is making lawyers rich and investors crazed on
speculation - will be appealed and go on for years and years. The
interesting thing about this battle is RIM reluctance to settle with NTP.
Obviously, they believed their case was strong but today's decision is a
major blow. Perhaps saner minds will prevail and a settlement will be
reached so both sides can really claim victory.