Not to suggest commercial radio is heading down the tubes but when it comes to audio (music,
talk, etc.) in the car, the most exciting battle is being waged between the iPod and satellite radio. While the iPod has tremendous buzz and million of loyal followers, Apple isn't taking complete advantage of the opportunity to take control of the in-car experience. Why? As it now stands, if you want to listen to an iPod in your car it either requires some kind of gadget from a third-party such as Belkin or Griffin, or the custom installation ($$) of an input jack or special connector. (Disclaimer: I've been using the Griffin iTrip but the reception is terrible in downtown Toronto because there are so many radio stations, it is hard to find a channel without some kind of interference). If Apple was smart, it would start striking more deals with the auto makers (much like what Sirius and XM do) to make an iPod connection a standard or a simple, inexpensive option. This would easily extend the reach of the iPod into millions of vehicles - many of them owned by people with iPods but not using them was driving. Apple is already doing business with a handful of auto makers such as BMW, Honda, VW and Chrysler to integrate an iPod connection into cars such as the Mini Cooper and the VW Beetle, but given Apple's marketing muscle, it's puzzling why these kind of relationships haven't been extended to nearly every car maker. Apple should also be working with car stereo makers to make an input jack for the iPod a standard feature.
As for satellite-radio, I remain far from convinced even though there are millions of XM and Sirius subscribers. From my own experience using a satellite radio, the lack of control was frustrating despite the fact there are more than 100 channels. When you boil it down, most people likely find 10 to 15 channels that meet their interests. But after awhile, the 10 or so music stations on your favorites list begin to sound repetitive because they must appeal to a large audience to be commercially viable. This is why the iPod could thrive as you drive because the user has the ultimate choice to listen to you what they want.
|
||||||||
iPod vs. Satellite Radio
by
Mark Evans
on Fri 14 Apr 2006 08:14 AM EDT | Permanent Link
Comments
Re: iPod vs. Satellite Radio
by
Pierre La,bert
on Fri 14 Apr 2006 11:04 AM EDT | Permanent Link
I just tought that now that Bell is offering Hi-speed wireless internet access in metropolitain areas, it could be interesting to have something like the Pandora's squeezebox for your car. It would sure beat the Internet Radio, but maybe not the iPod-in-your-car.
Re: Re: iPod vs. Satellite Radio
unfortunately, bell's high-speed wireless service is fixed rather than mobile so it is not designed to be moved about. it does let you move it from one location to another.
Re: Re: Re: iPod vs. Satellite Radio
by
Pierre Lambert
on Fri 14 Apr 2006 09:20 PM EDT | Permanent Link
Too bad, I guess that you'll have more chance with the Toronto Hydro project.
Re: iPod vs. Satellite Radio
by
Wayne
on Mon 17 Apr 2006 12:12 PM EDT | Profile | Permanent Link
I agree that iPod makes more sense than satellite radio. It would be nice if iTunes could be integrated into the GPS Nav system that many cars now have since they have large 7" screens that are easier to read while driving than the little iPod screen. Not only would Apple make iPods more useful for existing iPod owners, they would also sell more iPods to people who don't yet own them or who want to buy a separate iPod to permanently keep in the car.
By the way - isn't it unbelievable that in 2006 most stock audio systems for cars, and most aftermarket audio systems, lack a simple audio input. What's the deal with that! Re: iPod vs. Satellite Radio
I personally prefer the ipod and there are a few that I know who wouldn't prefer it. Mostly because they don't afford one and secondly because if you're not from US after a while you have a problem with the rechargable battery and you need to send your ipod back to US to change your battery which is around 50$ plus transport.
--- donate car |
My blog has moved.
Check out the new Mark Evans. It's part of my mini-blog empire that also includes All About Nortel and Twitterrati. You can subscribe to Mark Evans Tech by clicking on the RSS symbol above.
Check Out These Blogs
Search
Login
|
|||||||
|
||||||||